Understanding who can witness your will is a crucial step in ensuring its validity and your wishes being carried out after your death. While drafting a will is often seen as a deeply personal and straightforward process, it’s essential to follow specific legal formalities to avoid unintended consequences. One critical aspect of executing a will properly under UK law is the selection of appropriate witnesses. This article explores the legal requirements surrounding who may serve as a witness, the possible repercussions of selecting the wrong person, and answers to frequently asked questions on the topic.
The role of a witness in the will-making process is to confirm that the will was signed voluntarily, by the testator (the person making the will), and in accordance with legal requirements. Witnesses do not need to know the contents of the will but must observe the signing process and sign to confirm they were present. Their purpose is to provide evidence that the will was executed properly if its validity is later contested in court. Because improper witnessing can render a will invalid, understanding the relevant laws and best practices is essential for anyone creating or updating their will.
To be considered valid under the Wills Act 1837, a will must meet several requirements in England and Wales. First, the will must be in writing and signed by the testator. Second, the signature must be made with the intention of giving effect to the will. Third, two witnesses must be present at the same time to witness the testator’s signature, and both must sign the will in the presence of the testator.
Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own variations of will execution formalities. In Scotland, only one witness is needed, although other safeguards are typically recommended. Northern Ireland generally follows a procedure similar to England and Wales.
In England and Wales, anyone over the age of 18 and of sound mind can witness a will. They must be physically present at the time of the testator’s signing of the will and must then sign the will themselves. Previously, during the COVID-19 pandemic, temporary provisions allowed for remote witnessing via video link under certain circumstances. However, abiding by traditional, in-person witnessing methods remains best practice and is generally required post-pandemic unless new legislation is passed to extend remote witness allowances.
It is important for a witness to understand their responsibilities. While they do not need to read or know the contents of the will, they must be able to testify in court, if required, that the testator appeared to be signing of their own free will, was of sound mind, and was not subjected to undue influence or pressure.
One of the most common mistakes people make when executing a will is choosing an inappropriate witness. While legally anyone over 18 can act as a witness, not everyone should.
Beneficiaries and their spouses
Perhaps the most critical restriction is that neither beneficiaries of the will nor their spouses or civil partners should act as witnesses. Doing so does not necessarily invalidate the will in its entirety, but the gift to the beneficiary is rendered void. This rule exists to remove any suspicion that the witness might have influenced the terms of the will.
If you leave a bequest to someone and they witness your will, the law presumes a potential conflict of interest. As a result, the bequest they were intended to receive will fail, although the rest of the will remains valid. For example, if you leave £10,000 to your niece Jane and she acts as a witness, she would legally forfeit that inheritance. The law also extends this disqualification to Jane’s spouse or civil partner, even if she herself is not a named beneficiary.
Relatives
Although it is not legally prohibited for a family member who is not a beneficiary to witness a will, it is usually discouraged. This is particularly true for close relatives, such as siblings or parents, as their impartiality might be questioned if the will is contested. It is always safer to choose witnesses who have no potential interest or involvement in the estate.
Executors
An executor is the person responsible for administering your estate after you pass away. In many cases, they may be a family member, a trusted friend, or a solicitor. While there is no legal restriction preventing an executor from witnessing a will—as long as they are not a beneficiary—it is still better to select a disinterested third party. An executor who is also a witness can be a red flag in contentious probate cases and may give rise to disputes, even if no improper conduct took place.
Professional witnesses
Solicitors, accountants, and will-writing professionals are often asked to act as witnesses, particularly when they have drafted or advised on the will. These professionals are generally viewed as impartial and reliable. Moreover, since they are usually familiar with the law, it adds credibility to the validity of the will.
Using a professional witness does not incur legal disadvantages, and it potentially provides valuable evidence if a dispute arises later. In fact, when clients instruct solicitors to draft their wills, it is common for staff at the law firm to witness the will to ensure correct procedure.
Failing to follow the proper witnessing procedure can invalidate the entire will. The most common errors that can make a will legally ineffective include:
– Not having two witnesses (in England and Wales)
– Witnesses not being present when the testator signs
– Witnesses not signing in the presence of the testator
– Having a beneficiary or the spouse/civil partner of a beneficiary as a witness
An invalid will can result in the estate being distributed according to the intestacy rules rather than the wishes of the deceased. This outcome might leave loved ones without provision and could lead to expensive, emotionally taxing legal disputes.
To prevent these outcomes, extra care must be taken to ensure the formalities are strictly observed. Even small errors, like signing documents in separate rooms or allowing a beneficiary to witness the will, can have serious ramifications.
Over recent years, society has faced events that challenged traditional will execution procedures, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. During this time, emergency legislation in England and Wales temporarily allowed for wills to be witnessed via video conferencing to accommodate social distancing. However, these measures required strict compliance and are seen as a last resort rather than a new standard procedure.
These allowances were initially introduced in September 2020 and later extended, but they are time-limited and subject to change. Anyone wishing to execute a will under exceptional circumstances should consult a solicitor to ensure compliance.
Choosing the right people to witness your will is not just about following the letter of the law, but also about reducing the risk of future challenges. Here are several tips to ensure best practice:
– Choose witnesses who have no interest in your estate. These should be individuals who are not named in your will and who are not close relatives of named beneficiaries.
– Ensure that both witnesses are physically present when you sign your will. Later signing, alterations, or staged execution can invalidate the will.
– Ask witnesses to be of sound mind and able to provide testimony if needed. It may be prudent to avoid individuals with physical or mental limitations that could cast doubt on their competence.
– Choose younger individuals when possible, especially if your will may not be contested or executed for many years. This can help ensure their availability if the will is challenged in the future.
– Provide clear instructions to your witnesses about their role. While they do not need to know the contents, explaining the significance of their job reduces the risk of procedural mistakes.
Once your will has been validly executed, you should store it in a safe place and ensure your executors know where to find it. Importantly, if you make any alterations to your will, the amended version must be re-executed with new witnesses who meet all the same legal criteria.
Any replacement will or codicil (a formal amendment made to a will) must be witnessed in the same way as the original. Simply altering your will’s text or adding a note without the proper formalities will not be legally binding.
Executing a legally valid will is more than just putting your wishes on paper—it involves properly navigating the legal framework that ensures your testamentary intentions are carried out. Witnessing, while often treated as a procedural afterthought, is of critical importance in making your will legally binding. By taking care to select impartial and legally valid witnesses, you are protecting your estate from future disputes and giving your loved ones reassurance at a difficult time.
Seeking legal advice or using an experienced will-writing service can help eliminate ambiguity and ensure that every aspect of your will, including its execution, complies with the law. For peace of mind, do not underestimate the importance of the witness selection process and the need to follow the correct legal formalities in full.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
