Mental health conditions are a significant factor to consider in the context of Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) decisions, as they can impact a person’s capacity to make informed, independent choices. As society becomes increasingly aware of mental health issues and their effects on daily life and decision-making, it is important to understand how individuals with mental health conditions might navigate the process of granting, receiving, or acting within the framework of an LPA. Families, legal professionals, and healthcare providers need to take into account the intricacies of mental health when dealing with powers of attorney and ensuring the individual’s best interests are safeguarded.
Before delving into the influence of mental health conditions on LPA decisions, it is crucial to have a clear grasp of what an LPA entails. An LPA is a legal document that grants one or more individuals (known as attorneys) the authority to make decisions on behalf of the person creating it (the donor). There are two primary types—one that addresses health and welfare decisions and another that deals with property and financial affairs.
The health and welfare LPA covers matters such as medical treatment, daily routines, and life-sustaining procedures, while the property and financial affairs LPA enables attorneys to manage assets, finances, and property transactions for the donor. Both forms of power of attorney are useful when the donor is unable to make decisions due to physical or mental incapacity. Such incapacity may arise from various conditions, including dementia, brain injury, or more transient conditions such as mental health episodes.
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 in the UK serves as the legal framework governing LPAs. It outlines the criteria for determining whether a person has the capacity to create an LPA and helps define the responsibilities of attorneys. A fundamental component of the Mental Capacity Act is the principle that a person should be assumed to have capacity unless it is established otherwise. It is within this broader legal framework that mental health conditions play an influential role in shaping LPA decisions.
Mental health disorders cover a wide spectrum ranging from anxiety and depression to more severe conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or long-term neurodegenerative illnesses such as Alzheimer’s disease. The capacity to make decisions can be affected either temporarily or permanently depending on the nature and extent of the condition. Because mental health symptoms can fluctuate, the impact of these conditions on a person’s ability to create or revoke an LPA depends on several factors.
The crux of the matter is ‘mental capacity.’ Mental capacity refers to the ability to understand, retain, weigh, and use information to make decisions as well as to communicate those decisions. Loss of capacity does not necessarily occur uniformly across all mental health conditions or even within the same condition over time. For instance, a person with depression may have periods of lucidity and insight during which they can make sound decisions, while at other times, their ability to think clearly may be impaired due to anxiety, helplessness, or cognitive numbness. Similarly, individuals with bipolar disorder may have manic or depressive episodes that affect their judgment and decision-making competence.
The fluctuating nature of mental health makes the determination of capacity a very complex issue. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 recognises that capacity can vary over time and that a person may have the ability to make some decisions but not others. For instance, someone might be able to decide what to eat but might struggle to manage finances.
Guidance for families and legal professionals around these issues is provided through a capacity assessment. Conducted by qualified professionals, a capacity assessment evaluates whether an individual can make informed choices at a particular time. Attorneys should always ensure that the donor has sufficient mental capacity when creating an LPA, and any assessment should acknowledge that capacity can fluctuate, particularly for those with mental health diagnoses.
Creating an LPA involves many practical and emotional considerations, especially for individuals facing mental health challenges. Some key challenges include:
Fear of Losing Control: People with long-term or severe mental health conditions might fear that granting an LPA will take away their autonomy. The prospect of sharing decision-making with another person can be extremely anxiety-provoking for individuals who have faced considerable mental health struggles. It is important to convey that an LPA does not come into immediate effect unless specified otherwise. For instance, a property and financial affairs LPA can be actionable when the donor retains capacity, while a health and welfare LPA only comes into effect when the donor has lost capacity.
Stigma: Despite growing awareness, there remains a societal stigma around mental health issues. Individuals struggling with anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, or schizophrenia may feel hesitant about creating an LPA due to concerns of being judged or perceived as incapable by others. Their reluctance may be exacerbated by a fear that an attorney might act against their best interests or a misconception that the existence of an LPA will automatically involve third parties in highly personal matters.
Uncertainty about Prognosis: Some mental health conditions are episodic, such as depression or anxiety disorders, while others, like Alzheimer’s or schizophrenia, can progressively worsen over time. The unpredictability of how one’s mental health condition will evolve can make it hard for individuals to plan appropriately. This uncertainty can give rise to confusion or second thoughts about who to choose as an attorney and whether temporary or long-term powers are advisable.
Difficulty in Recognising Early Symptoms: One particularly difficult aspect of mental health disorders is recognising when loss of capacity occurs. A person suffering from a mental condition may not always acknowledge that they are impaired. In conditions like schizophrenia or dementia, early symptoms can manifest mildly, making it difficult for the person and their loved ones to realise the extent of incapacity on time. This can further complicate the timing and logistics of creating or invoking an LPA.
Another crucial part of the decision-making process is appointing an attorney who will act on behalf of the donor. This decision is particularly important for those with mental health concerns, as attorneys will be responsible for navigating complex and sensitive issues. When mental health is a factor in LPA decisions, several additional considerations arise when selecting the right attorney:
Trustworthiness: For individuals diagnosed with a mental health condition, the level of trust in the attorney is paramount. Both emotional bonds and the attorney’s capacity to make well-balanced and compassionate decisions are important. The attorney must have a good understanding of the donor’s mental health needs and lifestyle choices and should spend considerable time considering what the donor would have wanted, even if the donor’s condition deteriorates.
Ability to Work With Professionals: Those dealing with mental health conditions often require the support of healthcare professionals, therapists, and psychiatric specialists. It is vital that an attorney be able to collaborate effectively with these professionals. This ability ensures that the donor’s needs are not only respected but also supported in a thoughtful, well-informed manner.
Regular Monitoring of Capacity: Mental health symptoms can fluctuate, as mentioned earlier. It may be a good idea for the chosen attorney to continually assess the donor’s mental capacity and alert them if their condition changes. Attorneys should not leap to assumptions but base decisions on professional advice, remembering that loss of capacity in one area does not imply incapacity across the board. Competent attorneys should consult mental health professionals as needed to make informed, ethical decisions that relate to the donor’s evolving needs.
Compassion and Empathy: Above all, managing an LPA for a person with mental health conditions requires deep emotional intelligence and patience as individuals may have days when they are more functional and days that are more difficult. An attorney needs to remain empathetic through the fluctuations in condition, ensuring they approach the role transparently, without infringing on the donor’s rights wherever possible.
Just as an individual has the right to create an LPA, they also have the right to revoke it if they have the mental capacity to do so. Mental health conditions, however, can complicate the process of revoking an LPA. If a donor’s family, friends, or professionals believe that an attorney is not acting in the donor’s best interest, there are legal avenues for challenging or revoking the LPA through the Court of Protection.
In some cases, mental health conditions may impair the donor’s ability to recognise when an attorney is not making appropriate decisions, or conversely, they may falsely believe that a competent attorney is acting against their interests due to paranoia or other cognitive distortions often associated with certain mental health conditions. In such instances, professional review and mental capacity assessments are essential components of challenging an LPA.
One vital aspect of the decision-making process that is often overlooked is advocacy. Both donors and attorneys should seek support and guidance from advocacy organisations that specialise in mental health. Mental health charities, professionals, and government agencies offer resources to help navigate the complexities surrounding mental capacity, decision-making, and enduring documents like LPAs.
Family, friends, mental health advocates, social workers, and legal professionals can all play a role in helping the individual recognise their rights. Having a support network in place ensures more comprehensive care and decision-making pathways for individuals who are unsure about how to proceed, particularly when navigating the sensitive balance between independence and planning for future incapacity.
Time and again, delays in setting up a power of attorney occur due to the difficulties surrounding open communication about mental health. It is essential that individuals with mental health conditions and their caregivers or chosen attorneys have upfront dialogues about future wishes, taking into account what might happen if mental capacity fluctuates over time. Early and regular communication helps ensure that an LPA is put in place before capacity deteriorates, creating peace of mind for all parties involved. Discussing future health wishes can also serve to combat the stigma or fears associated with loss of control that often surround mental health issues.
Mental health conditions play a significant role in the realm of Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) decisions, impacting the capacity to grant, receive, and act within the legal framework of an LPA. The fluctuating nature of mental health conditions presents unique challenges and underscores the importance of thorough capacity assessments, empathetic attorney selection, and clear communication. As awareness of mental health issues grows, so does the need for sensitivity, flexibility, and support systems to protect the rights and autonomy of those facing mental health struggles.
Families, healthcare providers, and legal professionals are encouraged to collaborate, advocate, and facilitate ongoing dialogue to ensure that LPAs serve the best interests of individuals with mental health conditions. By addressing these factors thoughtfully, LPAs can provide essential safeguards while respecting the dignity and agency of each individual.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
