Creating a will is a crucial element of estate planning, allowing individuals to exercise control over the distribution of their assets upon death. It offers the opportunity to ensure that cherished possessions go to the right beneficiaries, dependants are taken care of, and personal wishes are respected. However, the process becomes notably more complex when one has estranged family members.
Estrangement can arise from a range of factors—family conflicts, lifestyle differences, geographical separation, or long-standing disputes. Deciding whether and how to include or exclude estranged relatives in a will requires thoughtful legal and emotional consideration. By handling these issues sensitively and strategically, it is possible to prevent future legal challenges and family confusion, while respecting deeply personal preferences.
Before drafting or updating a will, it is essential to assess your familial relationships realistically. This involves reflecting on which relationships remain meaningful, which have deteriorated beyond repair, and who might have expectations—whether grounded or not—of inheritance.
Many individuals face difficulties in evaluating estranged relationships objectively, as emotions and history often cloud judgment. However, it is necessary to set aside emotional responses and think critically about the consequences of including or excluding certain individuals from your estate.
Consider the following:
– Has the relationship been irreparably broken?
– Have any reconciliation attempts been made or are they still ongoing?
– Does the individual rely on you financially or emotionally?
– Could their exclusion result in legal complications or emotional conflict among other beneficiaries?
Documenting your thought process during this introspective stage can prove valuable in justifying your decisions later on, especially if disputes arise.
In the UK, the principle of testamentary freedom allows individuals to distribute their estate as they wish. However, this freedom is not absolute. The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 enables certain categories of people—such as spouses, children, and financial dependants—to make a claim against an estate if they feel they have not been adequately provided for.
Estranged adult children are a common source of such claims. While estrangement does not automatically disqualify a person from making a claim, courts will weigh various factors including the nature of the estrangement, the moral obligation of the deceased, and the claimant’s financial circumstances.
For example, the notable case of Ilott v The Blue Cross highlighted the courts’ willingness to award inheritance to an estranged adult child, despite the clear intentions stated in the deceased’s will. These precedents demonstrate that simply writing someone out of a will can be contested, especially if insufficient reasons are recorded or if the documentation lacks clarity.
To protect your will from potential challenges, certain legal strategies should be employed. These include meticulous documentation of your reasoning, ensuring financial dependence is addressed, and engaging legal professionals who can draft clear, robust provisions.
Although not legally required, it is often advisable to communicate one’s intentions regarding the will, potentially including the rationale for excluding or limiting provision for estranged family members. Open discussions, where possible, can mitigate surprise and resentment that might otherwise fuel litigation posthumously.
Of course, such conversations aren’t always possible, especially where relations are antagonistic or painful. In such circumstances, a written expression of wishes, also known as a ‘Letter of Wishes’, can serve as a private yet powerful tool for explaining the reasoning behind specific decisions in the will. While not legally binding, it can provide context to executors and judges, assisting them in understanding your motives and intent.
The language in such letters should be respectful, factual, and non-inflammatory. Avoiding blameful or accusatory terms prevents further escalating family tensions and instead positions your decision as thoughtful, balanced, and considered.
Choosing the right executors becomes even more vital when estrangement is involved. Executors are responsible for administering your estate in accordance with your will, and their judgment and neutrality can influence the overall process positively or negatively.
When estranged family members are involved, it is generally unwise to appoint people who might have a vested interest in the estate outcome, especially if relationships are strained. Opt instead for trusted professionals such as a solicitor, a financially literate friend with no stake in the estate, or a corporate executor.
Appointing impartial executors ensures that the administration of your estate is handled competently and fairly, reducing the emotional volatility that could arise from contested relationships.
If you suspect that omitting an estranged family member completely from your will could trigger conflict or court action, you might consider offering a nominal provision or a conditional bequest. This shows that the person was not forgotten or overlooked but that a deliberate and conscious choice was made.
Such gestures can sometimes dissuade claims by displaying a reasoned consideration. For instance, a small, fixed monetary gift accompanied by an explanation in your Letter of Wishes may suffice. On the other hand, offering conditional gifts—for example, inheritance contingent upon drug rehabilitation or familial reconciliation—can be controversial and may not always be enforceable. These clauses must be carefully drafted by legal professionals to avoid rendering the bequests void.
Alternatively, if full disinheritance is necessary, you could explore making donations to charities or causes that reflect your personal values and passions. In this way, your legacy supports ideals you cherished during your lifetime and can act as a statement of your priorities and beliefs.
Disputes over wills are increasing in the UK, driven by complex family structures, growing wealth, and misunderstood expectations. Planning ahead to minimise these risks is essential, especially where estranged family members feel slighted or treated unfairly.
To reduce the likelihood of a will being contested:
– Use a qualified solicitor to draft your will. DIY wills are more prone to being challenged and can invite costly disputes due to vague language or omitted information.
– Have a detailed Letter of Wishes that supports your decisions and reflects your intent in rational and moderate language.
– Ask your solicitor to undertake a capacity and undue influence assessment when drafting the will, especially if there are expected challenges. This can involve having a GP or specialist doctor confirm that you were of sound mind and free from coercion.
– Keep your records and documentation secure and ask your solicitor to retain copies.
All of these steps can bolster the credibility of your will and make it more difficult to challenge successfully.
Family relationships, financial situations, and legal structures are not static—they evolve over time. Therefore, it is wise to review your will at regular intervals, typically every three to five years or when a significant life event occurs. Changes such as divorce, death, reconciliation, new births, or the acquisition of substantial assets should prompt a thorough reassessment of your estate plans.
If reconciliation does occur with an estranged family member, this may affect their status in your estate wishes. Conversely, if a previously positive relationship deteriorates, you may wish to revise the beneficiary provisions. Ensuring your will remains up to date reflects your current intentions and minimises ambiguities or outdated clauses.
Updating a will should be done with as much care and formality as the original drafting. Minor amendments can be made through a document called a codicil; more substantial changes may require drafting an entirely new will and revoking the previous one.
The emotional toll of planning an estate while navigating family estrangement should not be underestimated. Feelings of guilt, anger, sadness, and confusion are entirely normal and may complicate decision-making. Seeking support from counsellors, estate therapists, or spiritual advisors can be helpful. These professionals offer guidance to help individuals balance emotional considerations with legal strategy, and they support you in achieving peace of mind regarding your final affairs.
Additionally, engaging with an experienced solicitor who handles sensitive family matters can bring reassurance. Such professionals are familiar with the nuances of estrangement, contested wills, and family conflicts, and they can illuminate paths forward that honour your wishes while protecting your legacy.
When estranged family members factor into estate planning, the path ahead can seem fraught with emotion and uncertainty. However, creating a well-thought-out will, grounded in legal soundness and personal integrity, provides an immeasurable sense of relief and assurance.
Clarity, consistency, and compassion must underpin every decision. By articulating your wishes clearly, choosing executors wisely, and documenting your reasoning extensively, you can minimise the risk of disputes and leave behind a legacy that reflects your values and preserves your dignity.
Your estate plan is a final statement of your life, priorities, and relationships. While estrangement may present unique challenges, it also offers an opportunity to make deliberate, meaningful choices in a complex family landscape. With foresight and professional support, it is entirely possible to craft an estate plan that provides for those you care about, respects your emotional journey, and endures legal scrutiny with grace.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
