Understanding how to safeguard your final wishes begins long before any legal document is signed. For many individuals, the will is a definitive representation of how they wish their estate to be distributed among loved ones. However, even the most carefully drafted wills can be vulnerable to challenges after death. Disputes over wills not only strain familial relationships but also delay the administration of the estate and increase its associated costs. By taking proactive steps during your lifetime, it is possible to significantly reduce the risk of conflict and ensure the smooth execution of your final wishes.
The law in England and Wales provides specific grounds upon which a person can contest a will, including lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, lack of proper execution, and fraud. Understanding these grounds is vital in structuring your will in a manner that pre-empts challenges. Combined with professional advice and open communication with potential beneficiaries, a well-planned estate is less likely to face contestation.
The first and arguably most important step in preparing a secure will is selecting a reputable solicitor or legal professional experienced in wills and probate. While it might be tempting to opt for an online will-writing service or a DIY will kit in order to save time and money, these options can lead to complications. High street wills that are poorly worded, lack clarity, or fail to observe legal formalities are vulnerable to being contested.
A solicitor who specialises in estate planning will not only draft your will but will also ensure that all relevant tax implications are addressed, provide guidance on potential areas of dispute, and help you navigate the complexity of family dynamics. They can provide professional advice tailored to your individual circumstances, such as asset ownership structures, businesses, or foreign property.
One of the most common grounds for contesting a will is the claim that the testator lacked the mental capacity to make informed decisions at the time the will was executed. Ensuring testamentary capacity is therefore essential. According to the legal precedent set out in the case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870), a testator must understand the nature and effects of making a will, the extent of their estate, and the claims of those who might expect to benefit.
To prevent possible challenges, it’s often advisable for a medical professional to assess the testator’s mental capacity at the time the will is made, especially in the case of elderly individuals or those with medical conditions affecting cognitive ability. A formal capacity assessment serves as crucial evidence to rebut claims of incapacity, and a solicitor overseeing the will should document all observations to support the argument that the testator made decisions freely and fully aware of the consequences.
Undue influence occurs when someone pressures or coerces the testator into making a will or including specific provisions that favour the influencer. Such influence can be overt or subtle, and claims can be challenging to disprove once the testator has passed away.
A robust way to minimise suspicion of undue influence is to ensure that the will is drafted in private, ideally in a solicitor’s office without anyone else present. Solicitors are trained to detect signs of coercion and can act to postpone the process if undue influence is suspected. A clear record of the discussions that led to the creation of the will, as well as documentation verifying that the draft reflects the testator’s wishes, offers an essential defence. Where there are major changes to a previous will, the reasons behind these changes should be documented thoroughly.
Solicitors ensure that a will is executed correctly, but it can still be helpful to understand the legal formalities required under the Wills Act 1837. To be valid, a will must be in writing and signed by the person making it, witnessed by at least two independent individuals who are present at the same time, and who also sign the document in the presence of the testator.
Witnesses should ideally not be beneficiaries or married to beneficiaries, as this could invalidate any gift made to them under the will. Keeping meticulous records of the execution process, such as who the witnesses were and the date it occurred, can help prevent future disputes.
While not legally binding, a letter of wishes is a document often stored alongside a will, providing context and guidance for the decisions made in the will. This can be particularly helpful if you are excluding someone who might expect to benefit from your estate or allocating your estate in an unequal manner.
A letter of wishes offers the chance to explain your personal reasoning in a candid and compassionate manner – for example, detailing the breakdown of a relationship or highlighting past financial assistance provided. It may include direction on the care of minors, the treatment of sentimental assets, or the intentions behind trust structures. Judges may refer to such letters when assessing the testator’s intentions or during disputes, so clarity and sincerity are paramount.
Life is full of change, and your will should reflect significant events such as marriage, a new child, divorce, or the acquisition of high-value assets. Failure to update a will in the wake of such events can create ambiguity and grounds for contesting.
For example, in England and Wales, marriage automatically revokes a will unless the will states that it was made in contemplation of that marriage. Similarly, neglecting to remove a former spouse may lead to complications. It is advisable to review your will every three to five years or immediately following major life changes.
Open communication is often key to avoiding disputes. Although it may not be suitable in every circumstance, discussing your estate plans with family members and beneficiaries can help manage expectations and reduce misunderstandings.
Transparency helps potential beneficiaries prepare emotionally and financially, especially if your decisions differ from traditional practices or perceived entitlements. Addressing concerns ahead of time gives you the opportunity to adjust plans where necessary and decreases the likelihood of disgruntled relatives resorting to litigation after your passing.
Trusts can offer an additional layer of protection and control over your assets, often reducing the risk of a contested will. By setting up lifetime trusts for certain assets, such as property or investment accounts, you ensure that these are managed according to the trust deed rather than the provisions of your will.
Trusts can be particularly helpful in complex family situations, such as blended families, or where you wish to support vulnerable beneficiaries without giving them outright control over significant sums of money. By transferring assets into a trust during your lifetime, the estate’s value may be reduced, potentially lessening the appeal to contesters who expect a share in your probate estate.
Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, certain people can claim ‘reasonable financial provision’ from an estate if they believe they were not adequately provided for. This can include spouses, children, cohabiting partners, or others financially reliant on the deceased.
Being aware of who might bring such a claim, and taking steps to address their needs within your estate plan, can be crucial. If you choose to exclude or limit provision to someone who falls within these categories, thorough documentation of your reasons – supported by legal advice – can help protect against successful claims. Some choose to make smaller, nominal gifts to such individuals rather than exclude them altogether in hopes of discouraging litigation.
Many solicitors now offer to video record the will-making session to demonstrate that there was no undue influence and that the testator had full mental capacity at the time. While somewhat controversial due to privacy concerns and potential emotional distress caused to family members, such recordings can serve as compelling evidence in court.
Combining this with a comprehensive paper trail, including signed attendance notes, meeting summaries, and multiple drafts with revisions and reasons, creates a credible narrative of the testator’s intentions and sound mind.
Even the most carefully prepared will can be challenged or invalidated if it cannot be located, appears damaged or altered, or has signatures that appear forged. It is essential for your will to be properly stored and for the executors to know its location.
Many solicitors offer storage services, sometimes free of charge, and some choose to register the existence of their will with the National Will Register, making it easier for executors to find the final version. Only the latest version of a will is valid, so earlier versions should be clearly marked as revoked or destroyed to avoid confusion.
The role of the executor requires a great deal of responsibility, integrity, and organisational skill. Choosing someone reliable and free from conflicts of interest is critical. In some cases, appointing a professional executor, such as a solicitor, may be preferable, especially where family dynamics are strained or the estate is complex.
Executors can have a difficult role in managing competing interests and maintaining neutrality. Identifying individuals who can fulfil the duties with competence and discretion reduces the likelihood of missteps that could later result in legal action.
While not part of the will-making process itself, being open to alternative methods of dispute resolution, such as mediation, can reduce hostilities and legal costs should a challenge arise. Some solicitors are skilled in preparing wills that contain clauses encouraging or requiring mediation before litigation.
Mediation allows families to resolve disputes in a less confrontational and more conciliatory environment and is particularly valuable in emotionally charged inheritance contexts. Preparing for this route in advance demonstrates a responsible and forward-thinking estate planning approach.
Avoiding a contested will requires more than correct legal phrasing – it involves foresight, honesty, and professional support. By carefully planning the structure of your estate, choosing the right advisors, and proactively addressing areas of potential conflict, you increase the probability that your wishes will be respected after your death.
Families are complex, and emotions can run high when inheritance is at stake. Taking the time to craft a comprehensive strategy, rooted in clarity, transparency, and legality ensures that your final wishes stand the best chance of being carried out as intended, sparing loved ones from prolonged conflict and costly legal battles. By embracing professional advice, maintaining open communication, and diligently documenting your decisions, you strengthen both the integrity of your will and the peace of mind for those you leave behind.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
