Drafting a will is an essential part of estate planning, ensuring that your financial and personal assets are distributed according to your wishes after your death. However, while a person may assume they have complete autonomy in deciding how their estate is allocated, legal limitations and considerations in the UK could impact these decisions. Specifically, leaving someone out of your will can result in disputes and legal challenges that delay the distribution of assets and lead to unintended consequences.
This article explores the legal framework for excluding someone from your will in the UK, who might be entitled to challenge such a decision, and the best practices to minimise the risk of a successful claim.
Under UK law, individuals have what is known as “testamentary freedom.” This means that you have the right to decide how your assets are distributed and to whom they are allocated upon your death. Consequently, you are legally allowed to exclude anyone you wish when drafting your will. However, this principle is subject to certain constraints, specifically imposed by the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
While testamentary freedom exists, courts in England and Wales can override a will in certain circumstances if it is considered unfair or does not make reasonable financial provision for certain dependants. Scotland has a different legal framework, which includes “legal rights” that cannot be entirely overridden by a will.
The Inheritance Act 1975 provides specific individuals with the right to challenge a will if they believe they have not been adequately provided for. The purpose of this legislation is to ensure that dependants who relied financially on the deceased do not face hardship due to being left out.
The following individuals may contest a will under this Act:
– Spouses and civil partners – A spouse or civil partner is eligible to claim regardless of financial dependence.
– Former spouses or former civil partners – If they have not remarried or entered into another civil partnership, they may be able to claim if they were financially dependent on the deceased.
– Cohabitants (unmarried partners) – A person who lived with the deceased for at least two continuous years before their death can file a claim.
– Children of the deceased – This includes biological, adopted, and sometimes stepchildren who were financially dependent on the deceased.
– Any other person financially maintained by the deceased – This could include an extended family member or even a close friend if financial dependence can be proven.
A successful claim under the Inheritance Act does not automatically overturn the entire will but can result in the court adjusting the distribution of assets to ensure that reasonable financial provision is made.
Disinheriting a spouse or civil partner is legally possible but often results in legal challenges. Marriage and civil partnerships entail financial obligations, and the law tends to protect surviving partners from being left without adequate provision.
If a surviving spouse or civil partner is left out of the will or left with insufficient financial resources, they can make an Inheritance Act claim. The court will assess their financial position, the nature of the marriage, and the deceased’s obligations to decide whether a reallocation of the estate should occur.
Unlike some other claims, a spouse or civil partner is entitled to reasonable financial provision for their maintenance, regardless of whether they were financially dependent on the deceased. The courts exercise wide discretion when dealing with such cases, taking into account the length of the relationship, the financial circumstances of both the deceased and the claimant, and the needs of any other beneficiaries.
Unlike some other jurisdictions where children have automatic inheritance rights, in England and Wales, there is no absolute entitlement for children to inherit from their parents’ estate if they are excluded from the will. However, they are eligible to challenge the will under the Inheritance Act if they can demonstrate financial dependence or hardship arising from the lack of provision.
Courts are generally more sympathetic to minor children or children with disabilities who require financial assistance. However, adult children can also challenge a will if they prove that the deceased had a continuing financial responsibility towards them. That said, claims made by financially independent adult children may have a lower chance of success unless exceptional circumstances are present.
In Scotland, however, legal rights provide children with the ability to claim a fixed portion of the estate, regardless of what the will states. This is known as the “legal rights” system, which guarantees that spouses and children receive a portion of the deceased’s moveable estate (excluding property such as land and buildings).
If you decide to leave someone out of your will, it is crucial to take proactive measures to ensure that your wishes are upheld and to minimise the risk of successful legal challenges.
Include a Letter of Explanation
One strategy is to create a letter of explanation alongside your will, explicitly detailing your reasons for excluding the individual. While this letter does not carry binding legal authority, it can provide valuable insight for the court if a claim is made.
Demonstrate a Lack of Financial Dependence
To reduce the likelihood of an inheritance claim succeeding, it helps to ensure that the individual in question is not financially dependent on you. If a person has been financially independent for a long time and has no reasonable expectation of continuing support, their case may be weaker.
Make Lifetime Gifts
If your goal is to direct your wealth to specific beneficiaries while ensuring others receive nothing, gifting assets during your lifetime may offer a solution. However, there are potential tax implications to consider, particularly regarding inheritance tax.
Use a Trust Structure
Setting up a trust can be a way to retain control over assets, ensuring that they are distributed according to your wishes without reliance on standard inheritance processes. Trusts can sometimes be structured in a manner that makes it difficult for disinherited individuals to challenge the distribution.
Seek Professional Legal Advice
Wills should always be prepared with legal guidance to ensure they are unambiguous and correctly executed. A solicitor can provide specific wording and legal provisions to strengthen your position. Additionally, they can help you understand whether you are inadvertently exposing your estate to legal risks.
Estranged family members may still have grounds to challenge a will under the Inheritance Act if they are entitled under the recognised categories of claimants. Case law demonstrates that courts consider not only financial dependence but also additional factors, such as the nature of the relationship between the deceased and the claimant.
If an estranged family member tries to claim, the court will examine whether the exclusion was reasonable, whether the individual had any expectation of inheritance, and whether there are compelling financial needs that justify an award from the estate.
While the principle of testamentary freedom allows you to leave assets to whom you choose, legal constraints in the UK mean that certain individuals can still challenge a will if they have been excluded or inadequately provided for. Taking proactive steps such as structuring your estate carefully, documenting your decisions, and seeking professional legal advice can reduce risks associated with challenges. By understanding the nuances of inheritance law, individuals can make informed choices that stand up to scrutiny, ensuring that their final wishes are respected while also mitigating potential disputes among heirs.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
