One of the most daunting tasks anyone must deal with when preparing a will is determining how to divide their estate. Often, individuals wish to leave their assets to specific loved ones, while choosing to disinherit others. This decision can be fraught with legal, ethical, and emotional complexities, particularly in the UK, where several pieces of legislation can influence whether your wishes will be upheld after your death. Understanding the law surrounding disinheritance is vital in ensuring that your final wishes are respected, and your estate distributed as you intended. Let’s explore the subject in detail to give you a thorough understanding of how disinheritance works in the UK.
Disinheritance is the process by which someone is deliberately excluded from receiving any part of an individual’s estate in their will. Typically, this refers to family members—children, spouses, or even other relatives—who might otherwise have expected to receive a share of an individual’s assets upon death.
In some countries, the law mandates that specific family members should automatically receive a percentage of an individual’s estate regardless of their will. In the UK, however, the situation is more nuanced and governed by a combination of statutory provisions and common law doctrines.
Under UK law, there exists a substantial principle known as “freedom of testation”. This allows individuals to distribute their estate to whomever they wish upon their death. Essentially, within certain bounds, you are allowed to decide how your assets will be distributed and who will benefit from your will.
This principle lets you cut someone out of your will if you so choose, providing you clearly state this intention. This is a powerful right, but it does not exist without limitations—especially where close family members are concerned.
Despite this general rule of freedom to dispose of assets, there are legal mechanisms through which a disinherited party can make claims against your estate posthumously. This is particularly the case where disinherited individuals were financially dependent on the deceased. This brings us to one of the most important pieces of legislation homes in on the rights of disinherited family members: the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
This piece of legislation is crucial to understanding disinheritance in the UK. Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, close relatives and dependents of the deceased have the right to challenge a will if it does not make reasonable financial provision for them. While the principle of freedom of testation still stands, this Act serves as a buffer for certain individuals seeking to claim against an estate despite being disinherited.
There are specific categories of persons who are eligible to make a claim under this Act:
– A spouse or civil partner of the deceased.
– An ex-spouse (or former civil partner) who has not remarried or entered a new civil partnership.
– A child of the deceased (including adult children).
– A person treated as a child by the deceased (such as someone adopted or a stepchild).
– Anyone who was financially maintained by the deceased at the time of death.
An important term here is “reasonable provision”. If a judge deems that disinheriting a family member was “unreasonable” in accordance with the situation at hand, they could order that the disinherited party receive a portion of the estate, even in cases where this contradicts the explicit wishes of the will-maker.
This is a critical term for anyone trying to understand whether a disinheritance will hold up in court. The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 requires that certain individuals receive financial provision from the estate if they were reliant on the deceased for maintenance or if they are likely to suffer undue financial hardship as a result of being omitted from the will.
Courts will typically consider several factors when deciding if a will has made reasonable provision for a claimant:
– The financial needs and resources of the claimant both now and in the future.
– The financial resources and needs of any other beneficiaries named in the will.
– The size and nature of the estate.
– The obligations and responsibilities the deceased had towards the claimant.
– Any disabilities the claimant may have.
– Any other relevant factors, such as the relationship between the disinherited individual and the will-maker.
Therefore, it is essential for will-makers looking to disinherit someone, particularly a spouse or child, to give careful consideration to the financial situation of the disinherited person to avoid litigation later on.
Disinheriting a spouse in the UK is particularly difficult due to how the law protects legal partners. While it is possible to exclude your spouse or civil partner from your will, it is also highly likely that they’ll have grounds to contest the will if they do not receive adequate financial provision. This is because a spouse or civil partner benefits from significant legal protection under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 and divorce law.
For example, if you are still married but in the process of separating, you may be tempted to disinherit your spouse. However, until your divorce is finalised, the law still regards your spouse as entitled to a degree of your assets.
The extent to which their claim might succeed depends on various circumstances, such as the length of the marriage, their financial situation, and how dependent they were on you. Additionally, UK courts often favour providing a surviving spouse or civil partner with reasonable financial support from the estate if it can be proven that such provision is necessary.
Children may not have the same strong legal standing as surviving spouses, but they are still protected under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. This statute equally applies to both dependent and independent adult children.
While you are legally allowed to disinherit your children, doing so can trigger legal challenges, especially if your children can demonstrate that they were financially dependent on you or if they are unable to support themselves due to injury, illness, or another vulnerability.
It is important to clearly outline the reasons for disinheriting a child within the will or through a separate letter. While this does not prevent the child from contesting the will, it can serve as valuable evidence in court, should your wishes be legally challenged.
It’s not unusual for family relationships to become strained over time. Emotional rifts, estrangements, or lifestyle choices you disagree with may create the motivation to disinherit a person from your will. However, it’s critical to have legitimate reasons that you can clearly express if you wish to avoid disputes later.
Common reasons that may drive people to disinherit someone from an estate include:
– Estrangement: If there has been a long-term breakdown in the relationship, this might be grounds for disinheritance. However, your reasons should be documented clearly to explain why an individual is not inheriting a portion of your estate.
– Financial Comfort: You may wish to leave your estate to other family members or charities if your intended beneficiary is financially stable enough without your assets.
– History of Substance Abuse or Gambling: Some may choose to disinherit someone who has a personal history of squandering money on harmful habits. In such a case, you may establish trusts with conditions rather than completely disinheriting to provide some level of provision without facilitating misuse.
In any case, documenting your reasons is key to making sure your decision not to leave assets to a particular person is resilient to challenge.
Some individuals will attempt to add a no-contest clause—a clause that states beneficiaries will inherit nothing if they challenge the contents of the will. While this can act as a deterrent, such clauses are not always enforceable under UK law.
In essence, you could include it, but it won’t necessarily protect your estate from legal challenges, particularly if the claimant makes a successful claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
If you do not have a valid will in place at the time of your death, your estate will be distributed according to the rules of intestacy. These rules prioritise certain family members—particularly spouses, civil partners, and children—who may automatically be entitled to part of the inheritance.
If you wish to disinherit someone who would be a beneficiary under intestacy rules, making a valid will is imperative. However, even doing so does not wholly remove the risk of them contesting the will, particularly for dependants and individuals protected under the Inheritance Act.
If you are considering disinheriting a family member or someone likely to inherit from your estate by default, it is essential to take the following steps to minimise the risk of your decision being challenged:
Disinheritance is a sensitive and potentially contentious aspect of estate planning. While UK law permits individuals to exercise freedom of testation, certain family members and dependents can challenge a will under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Careful planning, clear communication of your wishes, and professional legal guidance can help ensure that your estate is distributed according to your intentions. By taking a thoughtful approach to your will, you can safeguard your legacy while minimising the risk of posthumous disputes and legal challenges from disinherited parties.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
