The death of a loved one is an emotionally challenging time, and dealing with the legal procedures that follow can add significant strain. One area that may arise during the administration of an estate is the realisation that the will does not reflect the current wishes of the beneficiaries or fails to address changing family or financial circumstances. In such cases, there is a legal mechanism available in the UK called a deed of variation. This legal document allows for changes to be made to the distribution of the deceased’s estate after their death.
Deeds of variation can offer valuable flexibility in estate planning even after death has occurred. While they are not appropriate in every case, they play a crucial role in allowing families to respond to unforeseen issues, tax implications, or evolving family dynamics. This article provides a detailed examination of what a deed of variation is, why and how it can be used, and the potential advantages and drawbacks involved.
A deed of variation, also known as a deed of family arrangement, is a legal document that allows the beneficiaries of an estate to change the distribution of the deceased’s assets. Importantly, this can be done without the need to challenge the will or go to court. It is a post-death arrangement that, when executed correctly, is treated for inheritance tax (IHT) and capital gains tax (CGT) purposes as if the deceased had made those distributions themselves.
The document must be in writing and signed by all affected parties. It allows a beneficiary to redirect their entitlement from the estate to another person or organisation. This is often done for tax planning reasons or to rectify an omission or provide for someone not named in the will.
For a deed of variation to be effective, it must meet certain legal requirements. The primary conditions are as follows:
– It must be made within two years of the date of death.
– All beneficiaries who are giving up or redirecting their entitlement must agree and sign the deed.
– The variation must clearly indicate which parts of the will are being changed and how.
– The deed must include statements concerning tax treatment, if the variation is to be effective for IHT or CGT purposes.
There is also the need to ensure that any change does not breach other laws. For example, beneficiaries cannot use a deed of variation to alter a will in a way that deprives creditors or defrauds other interested parties. Furthermore, where minors or individuals lacking mental capacity are affected, the change may require court approval.
There are several reasons why beneficiaries might choose to rearrange the distribution of an estate through a deed of variation. Some of the most common ones include:
1. Tax Efficiency
Inheritance tax can be a significant consideration during estate administration. A deed of variation can be used as a strategic tool to mitigate IHT liabilities. For example, a beneficiary might choose to redirect their inheritance to their own children or a charity, both of which can reduce the taxable estate or attract reliefs or exemptions.
2. Providing for Omitted Family Members
There may be cases where the deceased’s will inadvertently or intentionally omits someone who is now considered deserving of an inheritance — such as a stepchild, cohabiting partner, or vulnerable family member. The existing beneficiaries may agree to alter the distribution to include that individual, strengthening family ties and reflecting the deceased’s likely intentions had they written the will more recently.
3. Equalising Inheritances
Family circumstances can change, and original provisions can lead to perceived unfairness. For example, one sibling may have received significant lifetime gifts, while another did not. A deed of variation can help balance perceived inequalities by altering the percentages or sums distributed.
4. Passing Assets Down Generations
Older beneficiaries might choose to pass assets directly to the next generation rather than accept them personally, especially if they do not need the funds and are concerned about their own estates becoming liable for IHT on future death.
5. Charitable Giving
Some beneficiaries redirect part of their inheritance to charitable causes. In addition to potentially fulfilling the deceased’s moral or philanthropic values, donations to charity can reduce the overall IHT liability. If 10% or more of an estate is given to charity, it can reduce the applicable rate of inheritance tax from 40% to 36%.
6. Avoiding a Legal Challenge
In situations where someone may consider contesting the will — for instance, under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 — a deed of variation can offer a practical solution without resorting to litigation. Negotiations and consensual changes can preserve both family relationships and financial resources.
The process of preparing a deed of variation begins with a review of the will alongside the beneficiaries’ entitlements. After identifying the areas to be varied, the next step is drafting the deed, with legal professionals ensuring it meets formal requirements and complies with HMRC guidance.
Professional advice is essential in complex estates or where there are competing interests. Accountants, tax advisors and solicitors may all play a role depending on the circumstances. It is crucial to calculate any tax implications to both the donor (the person redirecting their inheritance) and the recipient. Once the deed has been finalised and signed, it may need to be submitted to HMRC, particularly if tax treatment is to be affected.
The beneficiaries involved in the variation will also have to consider any personal tax gains or liabilities. For instance, while a deed of variation can avoid CGT at the point of death, the recipient of redirected assets may later be subject to CGT when they sell those assets. This makes detailed planning and advice essential.
One important consideration is how a deed of variation could affect welfare benefits. If a beneficiary redirects all or part of their inheritance and they are on means-tested benefits, doing so could be seen as ‘deprivation of assets’. This means they may be treated as if they still owned those assets when assessed for benefits such as Universal Credit or local authority-funded care. This could lead to penalties or disqualification for certain support.
As such, individuals in receipt of public support should seek specialist welfare advice before agreeing to such changes. Ignoring these implications can lead to unforeseen and serious financial consequences.
While a deed of variation is a powerful legal tool, there are limitations to its use. First and foremost, only the parties who are affected by the proposed change can agree to it. This means that if the person making the change does not have absolute entitlement to the asset in question — for example, there’s a contingent or joint beneficiary — all such parties must also consent.
A deed of variation also cannot be used to alter the obligations under the intestacy rules where there is no will, except by those entitled under those rules agreeing to changes. Furthermore, it cannot be used to remove liabilities such as debts or taxes that are legally due.
Where the proposed change affects minors or vulnerable adults without full capacity, court approval is typically required because these individuals cannot legally consent to a variation. In such cases, the Court of Protection plays a role in safeguarding their financial interests.
A central aspect of any deed of variation is its tax treatment. UK tax law offers favourable treatment provided the variation is completed within two years of the date of death and includes the necessary statements under sections 142 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 and 62 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992.
These statements declare the variation as being made as if it was contained in the will, thus avoiding CGT or IHT on the actual redirection. However, this status requires that the variation be reported to HMRC if it impacts the amount of inheritance tax due or claimed. For straightforward cases where tax liabilities are not changed, notification to the tax authority may not be required.
There is no relief from income tax via a deed of variation. Redirected income paid out of the estate cannot be shifted in terms of taxable responsibility, and the person who receives it must account for it accordingly.
When an estate contains business or agricultural assets, tax planning can become significantly more complex. Entrepreneurs’ Relief, Business Property Relief and Agricultural Property Relief may all play a role. Altering the distribution of these assets through a deed of variation can lead either to enhancing available reliefs or losing access to them. Each case needs detailed professional scrutiny.
In particular, transferring business interests to beneficiaries who cannot or will not manage them (or who are subject to restrictions) can jeopardise continuity plans. It might also affect the qualifying nature of such assets for future tax relief. Again, specialist advice is essential where businesses or land are part of the estate makeup.
Governments periodically review inheritance tax and related laws, meaning that the use of a deed of variation may come under scrutiny at some point. Proposals in the past have included limiting their usage or amending the tax advantages. As such, it is worth keeping informed on proposed tax reforms and the political climate.
In the meantime, transparency and responsible use remain key principles when employing this legal tool. Courts and tax authorities are alert to any signs of evasive behaviour disguised as variation. Professional representation and careful documentation ensure that changes are legitimate, fair and compliant.
Beneficiaries and executors should always maintain clear communication. Avoiding misunderstandings and ensuring records of why and how decisions were made ensures that potential disputes are minimised, particularly when sensitive family matters are involved.
A deed of variation is a unique opportunity to reshape how an estate is distributed even after someone has passed away. More than a procedural formality, it is a flexible legal instrument that can accommodate changing family needs, tax planning goals, and moral considerations, without the need to challenge a will or endure lengthy litigation.
However, it must be approached with careful thought, full consent from all affected parties, and professional advice to ensure compliance with tax laws and protection of vulnerable beneficiaries. When used appropriately, a deed of variation offers a practical, efficient, and respectful way to honour both the deceased’s legacy and the living family’s evolving circumstances.
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
COPYRIGHT © 2024 MY WILL AND PROBATE
